Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Journal Clubs: Home

About Journal Clubs

A journal club is a group of clinicians and/or medical students who meet to discuss and critically evaluate articles in the medical literature.  Journal clubs have long been a part of medical education, including one that Sir William Osler founded in 1875.

The ultimate goal of a journal club is to review research and discuss implications for clinical practice.

Tips for Giving a Journal Club Presentation

A journal club presentation should mirror the structure of the article itself.

  • Start with the background and definitions.
    • Start with a clinical case if it is possible so you can hook the audience in and get them engaged.
      • Present the case in terms of PICO!
        • Patient/Problem
        • Intervention
        • Comparison
        • Outcome
    • Provide background information on the topic and tell what the article was trying to answer.
    • Define any terms that are necessary.  Don't assume the audience knows what everything means.
  • Review the methods.
    • Discuss the study design, validity, etc.
      • Is the study design appropriate for the research question?
      • Can the results of the study be translated to the general population?
      • Is there any bias?
    • Discuss the article's internal and external validity.
  • Look at the results.
    • Go over the results of the paper and any figures/tables.
    • Are the results statistically significant?
    • Are the results clinically significant?
  • Have a discussion.
    • Talk about the key findings and implementing them into clinical practice.
    • Ask questions of the audience:
      • Are there limitations to the study?
      • What are some practice implications?
      • How can the results be applied?
      • What additional questions does the study raise?

Prepare a short handout for the audience.

Tips for Participating in a Journal Club

  • Read the article(s) prior to the meeting.
  • Be prepared to discuss the article.
    • How does the article apply to your practice?
    • What are some limitations of the study?

© Alabama College of Osteopathic Medicine Library ι Alabama College of Osteopathic Medicine ι 445 Health Sciences Boulevard, Dothan, AL 36303 ι (334) 699-2266 ext. 4242 ι Contact Us